Wednesday, November 02, 2016

on religious hypocrisy and authenitic community

Gospel of Luke 11
"While he was speaking, a Pharisee invited him to dine with him; so he went in and took his place at the table. The Pharisee was amazed to see that he did not first wash before dinner. Then the Lord said to him, ‘Now you Pharisees clean the outside of the cup and of the dish, but inside you are full of greed and wickedness. You fools! Did not the one who made the outside make the inside also? So give for alms those things that are within; and see, everything will be clean for you.
 ‘But woe to you Pharisees! For you tithe mint and rue and herbs of all kinds, and neglect justice and the love of God; it is these you ought to have practised, without neglecting the others. Woe to you Pharisees! For you love to have the seat of honour in the synagogues and to be greeted with respect in the market-places. Woe to you! For you are like unmarked graves, and people walk over them without realizing it.’"

Jesus was no lover of vain, empty religious practices.  Jesus was intolerant of hypocrisy, especially among religious people. They do what is expected of them publicly, but privately they are greedy and wicked.  They follow their religious rules in order to appear holy or better than others.  They go to church, but they have no compassion in their hearts.  They neglect justice and the love of God.  Jesus called them out for their hypocritical judgment, because they accused Jesus of abandoning right religious practices and habits.  Instead, Jesus practiced excessive mercy and radical forgiveness and selfless love.  He did this without the endorsement of the religious leadership.  He taught without their authority and consent.  He was more concerned about broken people than about broken rules.  He noticed that the religious system actually prevented people from encountering the God he knew as Father.  It actually replaced an authentic relationship with a living, speaking, acting God with a religious transaction---do these things and you will be blessed.  Fail to do them and you will be cursed.  The myth we still buy into today goes something like this:  If your life is hard, perhaps it is because you are not religious or faithful enough. If your life is good, it is because you are obeying God's will.  Suffering people may be faithful, but they are most likely in God's disfavor.  Doing what is right is necessary to have a good life. Blessed people prosper.  Cursed people suffer.   Jesus debunked this myth. A crucified man is supposed to be a cursed man, according to the Hebrew Scripture.  But he says the cross is the way of salvation. He says the poor are blessed. He says the sick and sinful belong to God. He says the vulnerable are our neighbors to whom we are called as servants.  We can see why religious hypocrisy causes so many people to reject Christianity and even God. 

Religious practices, including Sunday morning worship, can prevent us from living a God centered life.  Jesus implies that those who claim to have a relationship with God and have hatred for their neighbor do not really know God.  You can't claim to have an UP/DOWN relationship if you have no terrible OUT relationships.   We think that if we show up, are members of a church, pay our dues, and do the rituals then that satisfies God and insures us a place in God's care.  We can do our duty to God and never serve anyone else.  We can, in fact love God with our lips and hate our neighbors, especially those who are not like us.   

But, Jesus proposes an alternative to religious hypocrisy. For Jesus, the table was the place of radical inclusion, welcome, and encounter--where God is present in food and drink and human companionship.   He proposes an authentic life of love, mercy, and justice.  This takes place within the human heart first and extends outward through our actions and words.  Jesus shows us what it looks like to have an authentic relationship with God demonstrated in the ways we show love to other people. Jesus shows us authentic relational balance. It is costly.  It requires a lot of grace.  And he envisioned and established a community to practice it.  What if church was more like that and less like 1st century Pharisaic religion---a religion that drew very clear exclusionary lines between those who were in the club and those who were not?     

How have you experienced religious hypocrisy?  What about this alternative message appeals to you?    Who do you know that has been turned off by religious hypocrisy, exclusion, and bigotry?  How might you invite them to the table of grace?       



       

On the Difference between Right and Justified


Preached on October 23, 2016
gospel: Luke 18:9-14
[Jesus] also told this parable to some who trusted in themselves that they were righteous and regarded others with contempt:10“Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. 11The Pharisee, standing by himself, was praying thus, ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other people: thieves, rogues, adulterers, or even like this tax collector. 12I fast twice a week; I give a tenth of all my income.’ 13But the tax collector, standing far off, would not even look up to heaven, but was beating his breast and saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, a sinner!’ 14I tell you, this man went down to his home justified rather than the other; for all who exalt themselves will be humbled, but all who humble themselves will be exalted.”
Who are those who trust in themselves that they are righteous and regard others with contempt?  Not me. I’m not like those hypocrites, those self-righteous do-gooders who think they’re better than everyone else.  I’m a Lutheran.  We’re humble church folk. This is who we are and what we believe. Listen to these four statements: 

  • Know the difference between right and wrong and choose what is right. Do the right things. 
  • The bible teaches us the right way to live.  Follow the bible’s teachings and you will please God.  If you’re on the wrong track, turn around and get yourself right with the Lord. 
  • A right relationship with God and others is the key to a happy life.
  • God wants you to know that you are good, that you can do good things, and that doing good things for others is the calling of all Christians.   

Do these statements describe us?  I think we can all agree that these statements sound, well, right.  To a certain extent, this is what we believe isn’t it?  Christianity teaches us how to live the way God wants us to live, teaches how to behave, what righteousness looks like.  From the ten commandments to the Sermon on the Mount, from the prophets words of admonition to Paul’s Christian household codes, the bible is a manual for holy living.  Now, we Lutherans are taught that we are all sinners, incapable of following the law.  So Jesus was sent to die for our sins, freely taking my place on the cross, so that I can receive forgiveness and eternal life.  We call this amazing grace.  And it frees us from slavery to sin so that we can be the good people God intends for us to be.  As a result, we are encouraged to try harder.  We are free from the threat of punishment to work harder at doing God’s will, doing what is right.  Because of Jesus, we are able to confidently move toward righteous obedience.  We call this sanctification, becoming holier as we reject sin and follow Christ.  Our actions, worship and service to our neighbors move us closer and closer to sainthood.  The more we do, the closer we get.  The less you do, the further you get from God.  Non-practitioners of the faith are maybe more lost than unbelievers.  They don’t know any better.  Right>  but saved people should act like they are grateful.  Again, this sounds right in our ears.  This is the correct formula for a Christian life.   I suspect that most people who come to church do so to hear a positive message, an uplifting message and an encouraging message.  Mainly that God cares about you, that you are loved and capable of real goodness.  We love stories of people doing good things for others.  I suspect this is what we want Christianity and church to be about.  Feel good, do good, be good.  It is what we do or don’t do that counts for or against us.  Our behavior is a sign of our character.  Morality is the hallmark of the Christian life.  Salvation is the reward of a life lived well.  Either good people are saved or saved people are good.  This is what we have come to believe.          

So, Jesus tells a story.  Two men go up to the temple to pray.  One thanks God that he is a good man who does the right things.  He is upright, religious, faithful.  He brings no guilt or shame or remorse.  But he is grateful.  He contrasts himself with immoral people like the other man praying nearby.   The other begs God for mercy because he is not a good man.  He is a tax collector, a traitor working with the enemy occupiers.  He has guilt, shame, and remorse.  He is not right with God or others.  He is not a good person.  He has made bad choices.  Both men pray to the same God.  But only one man goes home justified.  Only one man goes home changed.  Only one man goes home lighter, freer, happier.  Only one man goes home with a new relationship with God, a clean heart and a clear conscience. 

To be righteous is to trust in our own ability, our own goodness, our own moral character.  To be righteous is to live in contrast to those around you who are not, who are wicked, bad, immoral, sick, depraved, etc…this is how we so easily ignore criminals, the poor, the addict.  Righteousness can become arrogant disassociation, detachment from those other people.  Righteousness divides people into good people and bad people.  And it is a false reading of the bible. 

To be justified is to experience myself as a sinner, to fall on my knees, to cry out for mercy, to hope for unearned acceptance, and to receive a great gift.  To be justified is to surrender one’s self to God, who might very well punish or reject you, and instead chooses to embrace you and welcome you home and restore you to your created self, child of God.  To be justified is to be clothed with Christ in baptism, fed by Christ at the table, crucified with Christ, and raised with Christ.  To be justified is to be seen by God in the likeness of Jesus.  We set nothing right.  When we try, we are more likely to sin.  Our work is to beat the chest and cry out for mercy and hope for God to listen and take action for you and for your neighbor.  Our work is to have faith enough to believe that God has the power and the glory forever.  Amen. 

On Reformations, personal and public



This weekend begins a year-long commemoration of the 500th anniversary of the Lutheran Reformation.  The Pope, once called the antichrist by Luther who was condemned by that Pope in 1520, is this week joining Lutherans in Lund, Sweden to kick off a year of commemoration with a joint worship service.  We are moving toward restored communion with Rome and historic levels of unity among Catholics and Lutherans.  499 years ago tomorrow,  Dr. Martin Luther posted his 95 theses on indulgences and the authority of the Pope on the doors of the Wittenburg Church.  Luther was a Black Augustinian monk, a Roman priest, and a university professor of the bible.  The result of his theses and the debate about them that followed was fuel on a fire that had already been lit.  By 1520, Luther was a heretic and by 1521 a fugitive from the law and both the Roman and German authorities.  In the years that followed, Luther and his colleague wrote the Augsburg Confession, a document outlining the principle assertions of the reformers.  What they said about God, Jesus, the human condition, salvation, and the church’s mission are not mere dogmatic statements, but a confession of what the reformers believed to be the truth.  Their rebellion was three-fold.  First they dared to believe in their own interpretation, their own reasonable understanding of the scripture.  They took as their primary authority’s scripture and faith and the grace of God.  The Pope didn’t like that.  Second, they dared to imagine and establish an alternative Christian community, a reformed congregation outside the confines of Roman authority.  Third, they dared to put the scriptures into the hands of peasants and ordinary people.  They took the great commission task of the church seriously.  As evangelical Christians, they saw as their mission to make disciples of all nations, baptizing and teaching them.  The Reformation gave the bible to the world.  Of course the danger in all of these things has been realized too.  There has been blood shed between Catholics and protestants, animosity, and discord. Only in the last century has some of that begun to fade.  Also, if you put scripture in everyone’s hands you risk its misuse, misinterpretation, and biblical idolatry. We continue to see how sin and the devil interpret the bible and use it to drive wedges between people.  But, Luther was a teacher of the bible who believed in rigorous study of the Word, in communal interpretation, and a theological education for all people.  This is, perhaps, what is missing.  Disciples, after all, are those called to be students of God’s Word. We are called to hear God’s Word speaking to us law and gospel, sin and salvation, death and resurrection, responsibility and relationship, failure and forgiveness. 

At its core the Lutheran Reformation is a daring, personal experience of the grace of God made known to us in the Word, the water, the bread and cup.  Faith is a living, daring confidence in Jesus Christ.  For Luther, the movement was always personal, always an inner struggle with God and the neighbor to live as Christ.  It was a struggle against sin, death, and the devil.  It was a struggle to love the neighbor, the enemy, the ignorant coworker, one’s wife and children. 

But salvation is given and received, it is not earned or rewarded.  The only condition of salvation is faith in God and in his son Jesus, a faith which is given by the Holy Spirit.  Faith is a particular way of seeing.  Even seeing God hidden in suffering, in struggle, and human failing.

 Zacchaeus was a Jew. Not a very good one according to most.  In fact, he had made full use of his privilege as chief tax collector, a member of the Roman occupation bureaucracy set to oppress his own people, by abusively forcing taxation and collection, with threats of prison and death carried out by Roman soldiers at his suggestion.  Luther said,  The Lord commonly gives riches to foolish people, to whom he gives nothing else.” Zacchaeus was increasingly troubled in his spirit about the damage he’d done and about is own status among his people.  He was rich, but despised.  And his wealth was gained by exploitation and violent oppression.  He hated what he had become.  So when he heard about Jesus, teacher of mercy and forgiveness, he wanted to see for himself.  Some said Jesus was the Messiah, sent by God to restore Israel.  ON his way to Jericho, just hours before, Jesus had supposedly restored the sight of a blind beggar.  Recovery of sight to the blind.  So Zacchaeus climbed a tree to get a view from the back of the large crowd from Jericho who had come out to meet Jesus on the road.  Jesus must’ve asked someone who that little man was perched in the sycamore tree like a sparrow.  Zaccahaeus, our chief tax collector, a fiend.  Did the crowds boo when Jesus approached the tree, called him by name and told him to come down so that he could host Jesus in his house that day?  They grumbled, He’s going to that sinner’s house? Anger and envy swept through the crowd.    Whatever they did, didn’t matter.  Zacchaeus came down and stood before Jesus.  Something broke open inside and he declared, “  “Behold, half of my possessions, Lord, I will give to the poor; and if I have defrauded anyone of anything, I will pay back four times as much.”  He will exceed the demands of the Law to set things right.  WHY?  To impress Jesus?  Or because meeting Jesus changed his heart?  We cannot know.  But Jesus declares, “Today Salvation has come to this house.”  In Christ, it is not your past or your future that are in question.  It is this present moment.  Salvation is both release from a troubled and sinful past and a promise of future glory in the coming kingdom.  But chiefly salvation is what is happening for you in the present moment.  What is God doing for you right now.  How is God’s Spirit changing the human heart right now, calming fear, bringing peace, offering comfort to troubled souls?  This is the ministry of the Gospel.  To apply the salve to the wounded heart. If the Zaccaheus’ can change, there is hope for everyone.  Salvation leads us to work that reconciles, work that heals, work that blesses others.  Salvation opens our hearts to serve our neighbors. 

Luther says that in Christ we are freed from sin to love and serve the neighbor.  It is this freedom that makes us disciples. The liberating grace of God that changes the human heart and makes us children of God and heirs of eternal life.  Today, the church is undergoing a season of reform.  Every 500 years or so, we need to do some housecleaning.  Freshen things up a bit.  Fix what’s broken.  In a divisive world, we see signs of healing of the old division between Catholics and Lutherans.  We are becoming something new.  As a church, we will not be what we were. We are becoming smaller, older and younger, and more attuned to the needs of our neighbors.  We must remain rooted in the Word as the source of our mission, faith, and life together.  And above all else, we put our trust in Christ who by the cross and resurrection has set us free from sin to serve all people with generosity and joy.  We do not celebrate schism.  We do not celebrate Lutheran doctrines that set us apart or make us more right than any other religious group.  We celebrate the grace of God made known to us by faith in Jesus Christ.  We celebrate that today salvation has come to this house as each of us here encounters the life changing Word, are fed and forgiven and sent to serve. Today, we are the church because we have heard good news that we have to share.  May we do so boldly, with confidence, for our neighbors.  Amen.        

Tuesday, November 01, 2016

All the Saints

Today is November 1st, All Saints Day.  Christians have observed this day for centuries, perhaps since the first millennia.  (Before 1,000 AD).  It is a day to remember the Christian faithful who have died, or fallen asleep, and now await the day of resurrection.   We often associate saints with people like Mother Theresa, Francis of Assisi, and Augustine.  And they are.  The Apostles of Jesus, early Christian martyrs, and desert monks are Saints, whose devotion to Christ accounts for the spread of Christianity in the first 500 years.  There are hundreds of saints, whose lives of very public faith, witness, and service demonstrate Christ to the world.  Roman Catholicism venerates saints, prays to saints, and celebrates saints throughout the Christian year. 
But, sainthood is not an unattainable condition merited to only the most devoted practitioners of Christianity.  Saints are not perfect people, or those who attained some special place because of their virtue.  Beyond the martyrs and holy ones who led exemplary lives, saints include all baptized Christians.  Saints live ordinary lives of faith and doubt.  Saints go to the bathroom and house the homeless.  Saints worship God weekly, pray daily, and eat at McDonalds.  Saints follow Jesus and follow the Chicago Cubs.

In my life, my parents and my pastors and Sunday School teachers were my saints.  They guided me, taught me, loved me, and called me into a life of Christian faith.  Bernie Gigliotti was one of the first people to encourage me to think about becoming an ordained pastor.  I still see him sitting on the pew in the narthex of Our Saviour Lutheran in Utica, NY.  I still receive meaningful counsel and inspiration from the compilation of Daily Readings from Luther's Writings given to me as a gift from Pastor Bill Preuss at a church assembly in 1994---two years before I graduated from college and seven years before I would be ordained.  I believe that assembly, filled with the saints, inspired me to serve the church as a pastor and evangelist. 

My wife and sons show their devotion to Christ every week as they share their gifts with the faith community.  My friends who gather around the table every Sunday, hungry for God to speak and give life to them, embody the life of ordinary saints.  We drink beer together.  We care about and for one another.  We struggle with each other.  We encourage each other.  We pray for each other and for the world.  We hope for things to get better and strive to be part of that hard healing work.  We feed hungry neighbors.  We grow food.  We accompany people through hard decisions, through illness, through seasons of suffering.  We try to live in community, to serve our neighbors, and to do things that matter. 

Martin Luther had this to say about ordinary saints:  "You say that the sins which we commit everyday offend God, and therefore we are not saints.  To this I reply;  Mother love is stronger than the filth and scabbiness on a child, and so the love of God toward us is stronger than the dirt that clings to us."   

If you're reading this, you are probably a saint who has inspired me in some way.  So, thank you.  You have shown the love of Christ to me and to others.  You are blessed.     

Reluctant Messenger

WORD: Jonah 3-4

"The word of the Lord came to Jonah a second time, saying, ‘Get up, go to Nineveh, that great city, and proclaim to it the message that I tell you.’ So Jonah set out and went to Nineveh, according to the word of the Lord. Now Nineveh was an exceedingly large city, a three days’ walk across. Jonah began to go into the city, going a day’s walk. And he cried out, ‘Forty days more, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!’ And the people of Nineveh believed God; they proclaimed a fast, and everyone, great and small, put on sackcloth.
 When the news reached the king of Nineveh, he rose from his throne, removed his robe, covered himself with sackcloth, and sat in ashes. Then he had a proclamation made in Nineveh: ‘By the decree of the king and his nobles: No human being or animal, no herd or flock, shall taste anything. They shall not feed, nor shall they drink water. Human beings and animals shall be covered with sackcloth, and they shall cry mightily to God. All shall turn from their evil ways and from the violence that is in their hands. Who knows? God may relent and change his mind; he may turn from his fierce anger, so that we do not perish.’
 When God saw what they did, how they turned from their evil ways, God changed his mind about the calamity that he had said he would bring upon them; and he did not do it."

I haven't written in a while.  I've been neglecting or avoiding this part of my call.  I know that I am called to write, to share a message of hope that comes from a heart and a mind of faith.  I have a lot to say.  But I have not wanted to say it.  I have been discouraged.  I have been tired.  I have been weary.  I have felt indifferent.  I have wondered why I am called here.  I have been frustrated with church, with myself, and with the uncivil national public debate. We are living in dark times, people.  We do not know right from wrong, good from bad, up from down.  There is mass confusion caused by a deep mistrust in institutions that used to be sources of truth.  Religious institutions are so divided that they are not trustworthy. There is political gridlock and real animosity.  The election of 2016 is symptomatic of some deeper problems.  Let's call it a crisis on every level; personal, communal, and national.  I have been reluctant to speak against the current situation.  Not unlike Jonah.   

Jonah is a reluctant prophet.  A prophet is someone who speaks a message of truth, a message from God.  The message is often discomforting, a little scary, and hard to hear.  It usually deals with infidelity and disobedience in the relationship between God and God's people.  Often social, racial, and economic justice are themes of the prophet.  Some prophets suggested that God is more interested in human equality and the ethical treatment of vulnerable people than in religious ceremonies and rituals.  Also, there are false prophets.  And discerning between true and false ones is important.  True prophets are often reluctant, unexpected, humble, and yet powerful in their delivery. Jonah is an authentic prophet. 
Jonah did not go to Nineveh the first time he heard God call and send him there.  Jonah despised the people who lived there.  He saw them as evil people, unworthy of God's mercy.  And because he believed that God was merciful, he feared that God was going to use him to announce mercy to those who didn't deserve it.  Jonah wanted God to destroy Nineveh. 
God will have God's way with us, though.  Eventually, after a stormy night and a fishy rescue, Jonah reluctantly goes to Nineveh.  He walked into the city and gave the least inspiring message that he could possibly give.  "In forty Days, Nineveh will be overthrown."  That is the entire message.  Seven words of pending doom.  Notice, Jonah does not say that God will destroy Nineveh.  His delivery was simple, powerful, and effective. 
Upon hearing this word, the people receive it and undertake a massive city wide day of humility. Even the King gets involved, decreeing a day of repentance, in the hope that God's mind might be changed by their changed behavior.  They hope to avoid the path of destruction by heeding the warning and taking public action.  As a result, God does change God's mind and does not bring calamity and destruction upon them.

Words matter.  Jonah announced a hard truth to the people.  They were not living in a way that was good, just, or pleasing to God.  But, people can change. The Ninevites publicly shame themselves.  They want to avoid divine wrath.  They fear that they are indeed destroying themselves.  I suspect people know when things are going in the wrong direction.   
God shows mercy, undeserved forbearance.  God changes from anger to compassion. 

We are called to speak hard truths.  God is not responsible for our self-destructive ways.  There is no one to blame but ourselves.  But there may be another chance.  We may get to try again.  We may get to make amends.  Guilt that leads to positive change is healthy guilt. Sometimes, hearing the truth is both painful and necessary. 

If I was told that I was going to lose everything unless I stopped doing something, would I stop doing it?  Would you?  What if I did stop, and my life got somehow better?  Would I tell others my story?
As we stand together on a precipice, what do we do?  What do we believe?  What matters to us?
I believe in the power of mercy, forbearance, and the prospect of justice.  I believe our political life can get better, if we learn to trust one another and see one another as brothers and sisters and not enemies. I believe that God sends messengers to tell us the truth, to wake us up, and call us to acknowledge our weaknesses and explore the possibility of our better selves.  I believe I am sometimes called to be that prophetic voice.  And so are you,  So pay attention.  Someone greater than Jonah is coming.

Reluctant Messenger

WORD: Jonah 3-4

"The word of the Lord came to Jonah a second time, saying, ‘Get up, go to Nineveh, that great city, and proclaim to it the message that I tell you.’ So Jonah set out and went to Nineveh, according to the word of the Lord. Now Nineveh was an exceedingly large city, a three days’ walk across. Jonah began to go into the city, going a day’s walk. And he cried out, ‘Forty days more, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!’ And the people of Nineveh believed God; they proclaimed a fast, and everyone, great and small, put on sackcloth.
 When the news reached the king of Nineveh, he rose from his throne, removed his robe, covered himself with sackcloth, and sat in ashes. Then he had a proclamation made in Nineveh: ‘By the decree of the king and his nobles: No human being or animal, no herd or flock, shall taste anything. They shall not feed, nor shall they drink water. Human beings and animals shall be covered with sackcloth, and they shall cry mightily to God. All shall turn from their evil ways and from the violence that is in their hands. Who knows? God may relent and change his mind; he may turn from his fierce anger, so that we do not perish.’
 When God saw what they did, how they turned from their evil ways, God changed his mind about the calamity that he had said he would bring upon them; and he did not do it."

I haven't written in a while.  I've been neglecting or avoiding this part of my call.  I know that I am called to write, to share a message of hope that comes from a heart and a mind of faith.  I have a lot to say.  But I have not wanted to say it.  I have been discouraged.  I have been tired.  I have been weary.  I have felt indifferent.  I have wondered why I am called here.  I have been frustrated with church, with myself, and with the uncivil national public debate. We are living in dark times, people.  We do not know right from wrong, good from bad, up from down.  There is mass confusion caused by a deep mistrust in institutions that used to be sources of truth.  Religious institutions are so divided that they are not trustworthy. There is political gridlock and real animosity.  The election of 2016 is symptomatic of some deeper problems.  Let's call it a crisis on every level; personal, communal, and national.  I have been reluctant to speak against the current situation.  Not unlike Jonah.   

Jonah did not go to Nineveh the first time he heard God call and send him there.  Jonah despised the people who lived there.  He saw them as evil people, unworthy of God's mercy.  And because he believed that God was merciful, he feared that God was going to use him to announce mercy to those who didn't deserve it.  Jonah wanted God to destroy Nineveh. 
God will have God's way with us, though.  Eventually, after a stormy night and a fishy rescue, Jonah reluctantly goes to Nineveh.  He walked into the city and gave the least inspiring message that he could possibly give.  "In forty Days, Nineveh will be overthrown."  That is the entire message.  Seven words of pending doom.  Notice, Jonah does not say that God will destroy Nineveh. 
Upon hearing this word, the people receive it and undertake a massive city wide day of humility. Even the King gets involved, decreeing a day of repentance, in the hope that God's mind might be changed by their changed behavior.  They hope to avoid the path of destruction by heeding the warning and taking public action.  As a result, God does change God's mind and does not bring calamity and destruction upon them.

Words matter.  Jonah announced a hard truth to the people.  They were not living in a way that was good, just, or pleasing to God. People can change. The Ninevites publicly shame themselves.  They want to avoid divine wrath.  They fear that they are indeed destroying themselves.  I suspect people know when things are going in the wrong direction.   
God shows mercy, undeserved forbearance.  God changes from anger to compassion. 

We are called to speak hard truths.  God is not responsible for our self-destructive ways.  There is no one to blame but ourselves.  But there may be another chance.  We may get to try again.  We may get to make amends.  Guilt that leads to positive change is healthy guilt. 

If I was told that I was going to lose everything unless I stopped doing something, would I stop doing it?  Would you?  What if I did stop, and my life got somehow better?  Would I tell others my story?
As we stand together on a precipice, what do we do?  What do we believe?  What matters to us?
I believe in the power of mercy, forbearance, and the prospect of justice.  I believe our political life can get better, if we learn to trust one another and see one another as brothers and sisters and not enemies. I believe that God sends messengers to tell us the truth, to wake us up, and call us to acknowledge our weaknesses and explore the possibility of our better selves.  So pay attention.  Someone greater than Jonah is coming.